The Star Employee Problem: When Top Performers Break Rules
Is your star employee causing problems?
I’ve got you covered.
Watch the Video
Prefer to watch instead of read?
Here’s the full video this post is based on:
“Jenn, I inherited a team—and I have a huge problem.”
One of the most popular, talented team members is a manager’s nightmare.
They bend the rules.
They violate company policy.
They expect preferential treatment.
Everyone loves them.
So do your customers.
But it’s clear they’ve never been held accountable.
And now you feel stuck.
Do you continue to overlook the bad and accept it with the good?
Oh, dear leader.
This is the worst.
Can You Just Take the Bad With the Good?
You can ignore it and accept the bad with the good.
But if they’re violating policies and you know it, then you’re complicit.
That makes it your problem:
- legally
- ethically
- culturally
Plus, when leaders allow inconsistent standards to persist, it doesn’t just create policy risk—it fuels resentment and exhaustion across the team, which is how many organizations end up facing team burnout in the first place.
So yes—you need to establish a new baseline for what is and is not acceptable.
Here’s how I’d start.
Step 1: Talk to HR Before You Do Anything
Not because you’re “going nuclear.”
But because you’re building a fair process that protects:
- you
- the employee
- the team
HR will likely tell you to:
- document patterns
- capture specific examples
But more importantly, they’ll help you choose the right path:
- coaching
- corrective action
- escalation (if needed)
Step 2: Plan One Very Clear Conversation—and Treat It Like a Reset
Given the complexity, you may want HR present for the first meeting—especially if this employee is already pushing boundaries. That said, you get to decide what makes sense for your culture.
Either way, go in with something like this:
“You’re talented. You’re valued. And your impact is real.
But some behaviors are crossing lines—and that stops now.
Consider this a reset… and a warning… and also a chance to succeed.”
This is where you give them a reprieve:
- “This is your warning.”
- “I want to understand what’s getting in your way.”
- “If this happens again, it becomes a formal write‑up.”
That’s not harsh. It’s clear.
Step 3: Get Curious About the Why—Without Excusing the Behavior
I’d want to understand what’s driving the “above‑the‑law” energy.
Sometimes rule‑bending behavior shows up when one person is carrying too much of the workload, which is why it’s worth examining whether chronic overcapacity on the team is part of what’s driving the problem.
Ask yourself:
- Are they burned out?
- Frustrated?
- Trying to protect the customer experience?
- Feeling underpaid?
- Used to being rewarded for chaos?
- Or… are they just used to getting away with it?
The goal isn’t to psychoanalyze them.
The goal is to identify barriers to success—and remove what’s reasonable to remove.
Then co‑create a plan that clearly defines:
- what success looks like
- what changes immediately
- what support they’ll receive
- what happens next time
Step 4: Clarify Expectations With the Entire Team
Situations like this are rarely about a single employee—they’re usually a symptom of the culture you inherited, especially on teams that haven’t had clear accountability in a long time.
You can say something like:
“My role as a leader is to advocate for you and have your back.
I’ll remove barriers, support growth, and fight for what you need.
And I’m also responsible for enforcing company policy and consistent standards.
Unless something is illegal or unethical, I can’t ignore policy because someone disagrees with it.
I will support you in seeking change—but I won’t violate my responsibilities to do it.”
This does two critical things:
- It protects you from “Why are you picking on them?”
- It helps prevent the star from turning the team against you
Risks You Need to Manage
Risk #1: Talent Loss
If you tighten standards, they might leave.
Start building a pipeline now so you’re not held hostage by one person.
Risk #2: Reputation Sabotage
When someone who’s used to special treatment gets boundaries, they may:
- rewrite the story
- play the victim
- recruit allies
- poison the room
Your counter is simple:
- stay calm
- keep it factual
- don’t debate feelings in public
- reinforce that accountability isn’t personal—it’s professional
Risk #3: Team Splits and “Takes Sides”
If the team starts picking sides, remind them:
“This isn’t a popularity contest. It’s a workplace.
My job is to protect the integrity of the team and our standards—consistently.”
That word matters.
Because when you’re consistent, fair, and transparent—
people can’t play you.
Best‑Case Scenario?
They grow up professionally.
They adjust.
They become a true team player.
They thrive.
And if not?
They move on.
And you’re ready.
A Quick Note to Team Members
This situation happens. A lot.
Your favorite colleague might be a nightmare for your boss.
And your boss is too professional to gossip about it.
One‑sided workplace stories happen constantly.
Assume you don’t have the full picture.
The Leadership Reality
This is one of the hardest leadership tests there is: holding someone accountable when everyone else loves them.
A leader’s job isn’t to be liked.
It’s to lead with integrity.
Consistency builds trust.
And trust builds teams.
So try it—and let me know how it goes.
Got a sticky workplace situation causing you grief?
Send it my way and we’ll tackle it in a future episode.
Thanks for reading—and as always, happy improving.